Resident Evil, a cornerstone of the survival horror genre, has captivated gamers for decades with its terrifying atmosphere, intricate puzzles, and iconic monsters. However, even the most beloved franchises are not immune to missteps. So, what went wrong with Resident Evil? Let's dive deep into the various aspects of the series that have drawn criticism, sparked debate, and occasionally left fans scratching their heads. The series has evolved significantly since its inception, and not all changes have been embraced. We'll explore the shifts in gameplay, narrative choices, and overall tone that have led to both triumphs and tribulations for this legendary franchise. From controversial design decisions to underwhelming plot developments, we'll leave no stone unturned in our quest to uncover the imperfections and missteps that have plagued the Resident Evil universe. We will also be considering various entries in the franchise, from the early classics to the more recent installments, to provide a comprehensive overview of the highs and lows of Resident Evil. Whether you're a long-time fan or a newcomer to the series, this exploration promises to be an insightful and engaging journey through the darker corners of Resident Evil's history. Get ready to confront the unsettling truths and uncover the mysteries behind the imperfections that have shaped this iconic franchise.

Gameplay Evolution: A Double-Edged Sword

The evolution of Resident Evil's gameplay has been a major point of contention among fans. The original games, with their fixed camera angles and tank controls, created a sense of claustrophobia and vulnerability that amplified the horror. Every step had to be carefully considered, and the limited mobility made encounters with enemies all the more terrifying. However, as gaming technology advanced, so did the expectations of players. The shift to over-the-shoulder perspectives and more action-oriented gameplay in later installments was intended to modernize the series and appeal to a wider audience. But this transition came at a cost. Some argue that the focus on action diminished the core elements of survival horror, turning Resident Evil into a generic shooter. The delicate balance between resource management, strategic combat, and exploration, which defined the earlier games, was disrupted. While the updated controls and camera angles made the games more accessible, they also reduced the tension and sense of helplessness that had been so integral to the franchise's identity. It is worth noting that the series has attempted to reconcile these conflicting desires, with games like Resident Evil 7 and the Resident Evil 2 Remake seeking to recapture the horror-focused atmosphere of the originals while retaining modern gameplay mechanics. These efforts have been largely successful, but the debate over the optimal direction for the series continues. Ultimately, the gameplay evolution of Resident Evil reflects the ongoing challenge of balancing innovation with tradition in a long-running franchise.

Narrative Stumbles: Plot Holes and Character Derailment

Even with its enduring appeal, the Resident Evil narrative has had its share of stumbles. While the overarching story of Umbrella Corporation's bio-weapons and the heroes fighting against them is compelling, the execution has sometimes been inconsistent. Plot holes, retcons, and convoluted storylines have occasionally plagued the series, leaving fans confused and frustrated. Characters who were once beloved have, at times, acted out of character or been sidelined in favor of new, less interesting protagonists. The reliance on over-the-top action sequences and bizarre plot twists has, at times, overshadowed the more grounded and character-driven narratives of the earlier games. One of the most common criticisms is the series' tendency to introduce new villains and threats that diminish the impact of established antagonists like Albert Wesker. The constant escalation of threats has also led to a sense of power creep, where the heroes become almost superhuman, further eroding the sense of vulnerability that was so crucial to the horror experience. Furthermore, the dialogue and voice acting in some installments have been criticized for being cheesy or poorly delivered, detracting from the overall immersion. Despite these issues, the Resident Evil narrative has also had its high points, with memorable characters, intriguing mysteries, and genuinely terrifying moments. However, the inconsistencies and missteps have undoubtedly detracted from the overall cohesiveness and impact of the series' story.

Over-Reliance on Jump Scares

While jump scares can be an effective tool in horror games, Resident Evil has, at times, leaned too heavily on them. Instead of building a sustained atmosphere of dread and suspense, some installments rely on sudden, loud noises and unexpected enemy appearances to startle the player. This can become predictable and ultimately less effective than more subtle and psychological horror techniques. The best horror games create a sense of unease that lingers long after the player has stopped playing. They make you question what you saw, and leave you with a sense of dread that permeates your thoughts. Jump scares, on the other hand, provide a momentary jolt of fear that quickly dissipates, leaving little lasting impact. Moreover, the overuse of jump scares can undermine the credibility of the game's horror elements. When players become accustomed to expecting them, they may become desensitized, reducing the overall sense of fear and tension. A more balanced approach, incorporating both jump scares and atmospheric horror, is generally more effective in creating a truly terrifying experience. The series has demonstrated its ability to create such an atmosphere in several of its installments, but the over-reliance on jump scares in others remains a point of criticism.

The Actionization of Resident Evil

One of the most significant points of contention among Resident Evil fans is the series' shift towards action-oriented gameplay. Starting with Resident Evil 4, the franchise began to incorporate more action elements, such as improved gunplay, more frequent enemy encounters, and a greater emphasis on combat. While Resident Evil 4 was critically acclaimed and commercially successful, some fans felt that it strayed too far from the survival horror roots of the series. Later installments, such as Resident Evil 5 and Resident Evil 6, doubled down on the action, with an even greater focus on cooperative gameplay, over-the-top set pieces, and a diminished emphasis on resource management and puzzle-solving. These games were criticized for sacrificing the tension, atmosphere, and sense of vulnerability that had defined the earlier Resident Evil games. The actionization of Resident Evil also led to changes in the series' tone and narrative. The stories became more focused on grand-scale threats and heroic protagonists, rather than the intimate and personal struggles of ordinary people caught in extraordinary circumstances. While the action-oriented approach appealed to a broader audience, it alienated some of the franchise's long-time fans, who felt that the series had lost its way. However, the recent installments, such as Resident Evil 7 and the Resident Evil 2 and 3 Remakes, have attempted to strike a better balance between action and horror, suggesting that the series may be returning to its roots.

Unnecessary Retcons and Lore Changes

In a long-running series like Resident Evil, some retcons and lore changes are inevitable. However, some of these changes have been met with criticism from fans, who feel that they undermine the established canon or create unnecessary plot holes. For example, the origins and motivations of certain characters have been altered in ways that contradict previous games or create inconsistencies in the timeline. The introduction of new viruses or mutations can also feel contrived or unnecessary, especially when they are used to explain plot developments that could have been handled in a more creative or logical way. Furthermore, the retconning of character backstories or relationships can diminish the emotional impact of previous games. When characters act in ways that are inconsistent with their established personalities, it can be difficult for fans to connect with them or invest in their stories. While some retcons may be necessary to streamline the narrative or introduce new elements, it is important to handle them carefully and with respect for the established lore. Unnecessary or poorly executed retcons can alienate fans and undermine the credibility of the series.

Underdeveloped Characters

While the Resident Evil series has introduced many memorable characters, some have been criticized for being underdeveloped or one-dimensional. Characters who are initially presented as complex or intriguing may later be relegated to simple archetypes or plot devices. This can be particularly frustrating for fans who have invested in these characters and are eager to see their stories explored in more depth. The lack of character development can also make it difficult to care about the fates of these characters, reducing the emotional impact of key plot points. Furthermore, the series has been criticized for introducing new characters who are simply not as compelling or interesting as the established cast. These characters may feel generic or uninspired, and their presence can detract from the overall quality of the story. A strong cast of well-developed characters is essential for any successful franchise, and Resident Evil's occasional shortcomings in this area have been a source of disappointment for some fans. The series has demonstrated its ability to create compelling and nuanced characters, but it has not always lived up to its potential in this regard.

Final Thoughts

Resident Evil, for all its brilliance, isn't without its flaws. From gameplay shifts that sparked debate to narrative choices that left us scratching our heads, the series has had its share of missteps. But hey, even with these imperfections, Resident Evil remains a titan in the gaming world. It's a testament to the series' enduring appeal that fans continue to dissect, discuss, and debate its every move. So, whether you're a die-hard fan or a casual player, there's no denying the impact Resident Evil has had on the horror genre. And who knows what the future holds? Maybe the series will learn from its mistakes and deliver even more terrifying and unforgettable experiences in the years to come. Only time will tell!